History and symbolism surround David Rutherford as he speaks with disgust of the controversies swirling in Vaughan.
"I’m embarrassed," says Rutherford, a 65-year-old teacher and son of Albert Rutherford, former reeve of Vaughan from 1961 to 1966, in the bucolic, pre-sprawl era of the 1960s and ’70s.
"City council is dysfunctional," he says with a look of exasperation.
It so happens that he’s sitting at the Al Palladini Community Centre on Rutherford Rd. W., under a plaque marking its dedication by Mayor Linda Jackson’s mother, Lorna, when she was the city’s popular and long-time mayor.
The centre is on a street named for Rutherford’s father, and just across the road from Basilico, the eatery much favoured by the younger Jackson for expensive taxpayer-funded dinners with assistants.
Rutherford is embarrassed by the notoriety brought by city council’s unanimous call last week for Jackson to resign – for a slew of reasons including her response to a controversial audit of her office expenses. He’s embarrassed by the back stories, too, recalling the phone call he got from his son in Kelowna, B.C., snickering about the recent arrest of Jackson’s husband on drunk and disorderly charges.
Embarrassed isn’t the only word Vaughan residents were hurling this week about their politicians: anger, frustration, even comedy. Some are mad at Jackson for her failures as a leader, others at the council for ganging up on her.
Yet they spoke with immense pride and affection for their city, as if the political shenanigans at city hall bear no connection to the smooth functioning of one of the fastest-growing and wealthiest cities in the GTA.
That’s why some residents like Steven Del Duca and Elliott Silverstein are quietly beginning to wonder whether long-term damage could occur, if the current political dramas continue.
The two are members of a city committee called the Task Force on Democratic Participation and Renewal, a group committed to increasing municipal voter engagement
"There is really an unfortunate but almost complete disconnect between what’s happening in that council chamber and the community – all the good things that are happening out there," said Del Duca, former executive assistant to former Ontario finance minister Greg Sorbara.
Councillors need to get their act together because there’s a point at which in-fighting and perceived dysfunction starts to damage the city in more tangible ways, he said.
Vaughan is at a critical stage: a slew of major infrastructure projects are in the works – a hospital, a new downtown, and highway extensions – none guaranteed.
"Any one of these alone is a big deal, but put together it represents billions of dollars of investment that we are hoping other levels of government will make in Vaughan," Del Duca said.
"It’s not just about bruising our civic pride and ego. One has to wonder how much the private sector and other levels of government will want to invest in Vaughan if we appear to not be able to manage ourselves adequately."
Silverstein, a former council candidate, said he’s concerned that despite a long history of controversy and Vaughan’s love of the political game, the level of voter engagement in municipal elections in Vaughan is very low – 20 to 30 per cent – showing a disenchanted electorate.
It’s not likely to improve with the current antics at city hall.
"This is a situation that has gotten worse over the last few years since the last election, but it’s something that has brewing for many years," he said.
Silverstein said it wasn’t Jackson all the time. "In the previous council (2003 to 2006) there was a lot of tension between the members, but now it has shifted," he said. "It’s almost two-pronged. There is continued in-fighting among the council but also direct frustration and hostility towards the mayor."
The call for change may not be that loud yet because, despite the nasty noises coming out of council chambers, for the most part Vaughan works efficiently and well. The city is blessed with a central location served by three 400-series highways, the potential remains for massive growth, and a subway line is expected to arrive soon near Jane St. and Highway 7.
There’s untold potential for commercial taxes to fill municipal coffers when a yet-untapped business enterprise zone in the west end is one day served by a proposed extension of Highway 427 health insurance quotes. The city receives hundreds of millions of dollars in building permit fees every year, has extensive recreation and park facilities, and is looking forward to completing a spanking new $100 million city hall.
All in all, it’s a relatively easy and affordable place to do business and an attractive place to live.
What’s to blame for the political sniping – which doesn’t seem to be about actual civic issues – depends on whom you ask.
Several councillors have said Jackson is to blame for provoking various audits and investigations, whatever the motivations of those who launched them. Jackson has tried to put the blame on councillors and a small group of public detractors.
Some of the hostility may stem from the fact these councillors (Alan Shefman and Sandra Yeung Racco excepted) have known each other too long and perhaps too well, having served not only with Jackson’s predecessor, Michael Di Biase, but also her late mother.
Several have publicly chastised Jackson for not possessing her mother’s work ethic or abilities, saying their disrespect derives from her apparent lack of interest in city business beyond ribbon-cutting and photo-ops.
The mess reflects a confluence of bitter attacks and audit challenges by disenchanted ex-supporters – who haven’t forgiven Jackson for campaigning to "clean up" city hall and then failing to push for an inquiry into alleged misbehaviour after the election – and a council composed almost entirely of people who endorsed the narrowly defeated Di Biase in 2006.
Some critics charge that Jackson just doesn’t have the ability or inclination to forge alliances and lead.
Voters haven’t been all that receptive to the arguments on either side, many saying council has no choice but to work together.
Yet the drama gripping city hall is being closely followed, and everyone seems to have an opinion.
Adriana Stalteri, 34, a pharmacy operations manager who was dropping off her son Lucas at the community centre’s pre-school, said she’s sympathetic to the fact Jackson has been under attack from Di Biase supporters since the day she took office.
"I don’t get angered; I’m sure Michael Di Biase did it prior to (Jackson)," she said of the mayor’s penchant for pricey lunches with wine. "I’m sure others have done it."
The auditor’s report said the meals were legitimate under city guidelines, but the harsh attacks that followed it led to Jackson’s announcement this week that she would no longer use taxpayer money for alcoholic beverages.
Stalteri said the energy spent on petty squabbling would be better spent making a city even more attractive to young families.
However, Roger Dickinson, 69, and his wife Nina Szymanska, 61, both Kleinburg residents, had harsh words for Jackson, saying the mayor had failed miserably as a leader, and blamed the crisis on her inability to pull council together.
Dickinson believes Jackson got elected on the coattails of her popular mother, but doesn’t have the "the common sense or smarts," to survive in the rough and tumble world of Vaughan politics.
"(Jackson) just cannot lead a team, unlike her mother, who to my knowledge was very good at leading council," said Dickinson. He said he was astounded by reports that Jackson had filed more than $13,000 in expense claims with no receipts, which were nevertheless approved by a senior official.
Rutherford said that while Jackson seems to have shown poor political judgment, she had three strikes against her from the beginning, from people hell-bent on seeing her fail. He doesn’t believe anybody in council is sinless, and they have no choice but to work together, even if it means appointing a mediator to straighten things out.
"There’s nothing they can do to get rid of her," said Rutherford. "She’s there, so folks, you made your bed. She got elected. Now let’s work together."
Otherwise?
"Unless you start working together, the best thing that could happen is that we (the voters) could find people who would run, and the whole bunch of them get hoofed."
Source